Has Black Friday gone too far?

Ahh, Black Friday. That magical time of year when suddenly every business you've ever bought from, looked at, or accidentally made eye contact with on Instagram decides it's time to give you a discount.

Traditionally, Black Friday falls on the Friday immediately following Thanksgiving in the US (27 November this year), and has become one of the biggest shopping events on the calendar. A day where businesses put their best offers forward, consumers get to bag themselves a bargain, and everyone's generally pretty happy with the arrangement.

Except, somewhere along the way, things got a little out of hand.

What was once a 24-hour shopping event has somehow turned into a 49-week fiesta. Which is quite the achievement considering there are only 52 weeks in a year. We're now seeing Black Friday campaigns start weeks, sometimes months, before the actual date, with businesses practically tripping over themselves to be the first to announce a discount. And after all that anticipation, we're often rewarded with a whopping 10% off selected styles. Groundbreaking.

I don't know about you, but I'm starting to feel like the whole thing has lost a little bit of its magic. What was supposed to be an opportunity to grab a genuinely good deal has become an endless cycle of discounts, urgency marketing and businesses competing to see who can convince us to part with our money first.

And quite frankly, I'm over it.

It's no secret that some businesses gradually increase their prices throughout the year, only to slash them back down again for Black Friday. Suddenly, you're being presented with the deal of a lifetime, when in reality, you're paying roughly what the product cost before its little inflation makeover. Then there's the fashion industry. I'm looking directly at you. Some brands produce Black Friday-specific collections, often using cheaper materials and lower manufacturing costs, allowing them to advertise a discount while protecting their margins. You're not necessarily getting the same product for less. You're potentially getting a different product altogether. And don't even get me started on the phrase 'UP TO 80% OFF'. Because yes, technically, one item might be 80% off. But it's one item, and it's usually something nobody wanted in the first place. Meanwhile, the rest of the website is sitting there offering 10% off like it's done you a personal favour.

So, what's actually going on?

We're living through a pretty uncomfortable economic climate. Household expenses are climbing, interest rates have been doing their little dance (and we’d like for it to stop RBA if you’re reading this), and businesses that have been operating since the dawn of time are suddenly going into administration left, right and centre. It's a pretty fucking scary time to be alive, and naturally, the way we're spending our money is changing.

My unfinished psychology degree tells me that consumer behaviour has a lot to say about this. When money feels tight, I think we tend to fall into one of two camps. The first is the 'spend it before it disappears' approach. We're anxious about money, worried about the future and feeling a general lack of control over our finances. So, when an opportunity to save a little money presents itself, we jump on it. Buying something gives us a little hit of dopamine, a momentary feeling of control and, occasionally, the illusion that we've made a financially responsible decision. Because technically, we saved $40. Never mind the fact that we spent $160 to do it.

Then there's camp two: clutching our pearls. We're cancelling dinner reservations, skipping our morning coffee, avoiding the shops and generally refusing to spend money on anything that isn't absolutely essential. We become incredibly good at telling ourselves we don't need anything. Except when our child desperately needs another Paw Patrol vehicle, apparently. Priorities. Either way, when Black Friday rolls around, we're suddenly thinking, 'Well, fuck. If I'm going to have to buy things anyway, I may as well save a little money.'

And that's precisely where the clever marketing comes in.

Black Friday seems to start earlier and earlier every single year. What was once a single day has become a month-long campaign, with businesses doing everything they can to get in front of you before their competitors do. Google Ads following you around the internet? Yep. Instagram showing you the exact pair of shoes you looked at three weeks ago? Absolutely. An email in your inbox every morning reminding you that you're missing out? Naturally. A text message at 7:03am telling you that your 15% discount is about to expire? Good morning to you too.

It's urgency marketing, and it's bloody effective. Countdown timers, limited-time offers, low-stock notifications and endless reminders are all designed to make you feel like you need to act now, because if you don't, you might miss out. And FOMO is a very powerful little marketing tool.

But while the big brands have entire marketing departments, advertising budgets and profit margins that allow them to play this game, smaller businesses are often left trying to compete with a very different set of resources. Which brings me to my next point.

Small businesses make up a HUGE portion of Australian businesses. They're the independent retailers, makers, creatives, designers and service providers who are often competing against brands with considerably more money, manpower and buying power. And trying to compete with those businesses on price can feel almost impossible.

The unfortunate reality is that some consumers simply don't care that your handmade product is made using sustainably sourced materials, that you pay fair wages throughout your supply chain or that you've gone to considerable lengths to ensure your production process is ethical and environmentally conscious. They care that they can get something similar for $2 on TEMU.

And look, I'm not here to tell anyone how to spend their money. But we do need to talk about what's happening. Platforms like TEMU and SHEIN (yuck, by the way) have been repeatedly criticised for copying independent designers and small businesses, reproducing their designs at a fraction of the price and selling them at a scale that smaller businesses simply cannot compete with. How exactly are we expecting a $2 product to cover the cost of materials, manufacturing, shipping, wages and quality control? I'll leave that one with you. And while we're at it, perhaps we should be asking what those materials are doing to our skin, what chemicals are involved and what the actual environmental cost of producing and shipping these products might be. But sure, it's cheaper. So there's that.

The point is, when we only compare businesses on price, we're ignoring an enormous part of the value they're actually providing. And for small businesses, that can be incredibly damaging.

Here's a revolutionary little idea: you don't have to participate in Black Friday. Not as a consumer, and certainly not as a business.

I personally don't participate as a business because House of Zemi offers services. I'm the person doing the work, delivering the strategy, creating the content and managing the projects. Discounting my services just because everyone else is having a sale doesn't particularly appeal to me. And I don't think it should be something businesses feel pressured into doing. If you're a product-based business, discounting your products might make sense. But if your margins are already tight, or you simply can't afford to reduce your prices, you don't need to.

Take Gentle Habits, for example. They've publicly shared their decision not to participate in Black Friday sales, opting instead to celebrate their own birthday with a sale at a different time of year. And honestly? I love that. They've created their own opportunity to celebrate their business without feeling the need to follow the crowd. Imagine that.

There are also plenty of ways to get involved in the Black Friday conversation without slashing your prices and hoping for the best.

You could introduce a new product or service with an introductory offer, clear out discontinued stock, offer a gift with purchase, create a mystery bundle for orders over a certain amount or reward your existing customers with early access to something exclusive. You could even use the opportunity to launch something new rather than discounting something you've already been selling all year. There are plenty of ways to create an attractive offer without necessarily eating into your profit margins.

And if none of those options feel right for your business? Don't do them either.

I think we've reached a point where the excitement of getting a good deal has been replaced by the pressure to constantly be buying something. There's always another sale, another discount, another limited-time offer and another reason to spend money. And somewhere in all of that noise, we've lost a little bit of the enjoyment of actually shopping.

As consumers, we can be a little more intentional about where we're spending our money. Support the small businesses doing good things, buy from people whose values align with yours and remember that just because something is discounted doesn't mean you need it.

And as business owners, we need to stop feeling like we have to participate in every marketing event, trend or promotional opportunity just because everyone else is doing it. Not every business needs a Black Friday sale. Not every brand needs to jump on every trend. And not every marketing opportunity is necessarily a good opportunity for your business.

A little reminder that everything in this world is made up. The rules, the trends, the marketing calendars and the expectation that every business needs to do the exact same thing at the exact same time. There is more than one way to run a business, and you don't need to do something that doesn't feel right for yours just because everyone else is doing it.

So, if Black Friday doesn't feel right for your business, don't participate. You have permission to sit this one out.

And if you do decide to have a sale, please, for the love of all things marketing, make it an actual good one.

Nobody needs another 10% off selected styles.

Next
Next

Have we all collectively lost the plot?